Accountability Before Political Speculation
Indonesia’s post-2024 election political dynamics demonstrate that relationships among political elites are never entirely static. Coalitions may shift, political support may be renegotiated, and relations between the president and actors who previously supported him may undergo adjustments. Within a presidential system, such developments are a normal part of the dynamics of political power. However, the situation becomes different when every political change is interpreted as part of a hidden scenario without sufficient supporting evidence. Political explanations that rely excessively on assumptions about personal motives risk obscuring more fundamental issues, particularly when the events in question involve legal proceedings, the authority of state institutions, and the accountability of public officials.
In a democratic state, changes in political positions and shifts in the configuration of power do not, in themselves, indicate the existence of a consolidation operation orchestrated by a particular actor. Such developments may arise from various factors, including competing interests, coalition negotiations, electoral calculations, institutional considerations, and the consequences of legal proceedings. Connecting all these events into a single political strategy requires evidence of causal relationships, not merely chronological sequences or overlapping interests. The fact that an actor benefits from a particular event does not prove that the actor designed or controlled it. In political analysis, distinguishing between political advantage, the capacity to exercise control, and direct involvement is fundamental and should not be overlooked.
This distinction is particularly important when examining the controversy surrounding Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational documents. The case cannot be reduced to the political relationship between President Prabowo Subianto and former President Joko Widodo. Through Decision No. 742 K/TUN/2026, the Supreme Court granted the cassation appeal, declared the educational equivalency certificate at the centre of the dispute invalid, and ordered the issuing authority to revoke it. The relevant ministry subsequently issued a revocation decision on 11 November 2026 in compliance with the ruling. This constitutes a concrete legal and administrative consequence, rather than merely a political development that can be interpreted through the personal relationships among political elites.
However, analytical accuracy also requires conclusions to remain within the scope of the court’s ruling. Case No. 742 K/TUN/2026 concerned an administrative dispute over the validity of a certificate issued by an administrative authority. It was not a ruling that directly annulled the office of the Vice President. The decision must therefore be understood in terms of its subject matter, legal reasoning, and the administrative consequences established by the court. Accordingly, two equally excessive conclusions should be avoided: dismissing the administrative issue as insignificant because the individual concerned has already been inaugurated, or assuming that the annulment of the certificate automatically terminates the constitutional legitimacy of the vice-presidential office. Both positions conflate administrative law with the constitutional mechanisms governing the appointment and removal of public officials.
This is where the principle of the rule of law must be applied consistently. Public office does not grant immunity from legal scrutiny, but legal proceedings must not be extended beyond the authority and consequences legitimately established by legislation. Court decisions must be respected and implemented, while any subsequent matters must be resolved through the appropriate constitutional mechanisms. Likewise, an official’s resignation, if submitted, does not automatically eliminate the need to ensure that the relevant constitutional and administrative procedures have been fulfilled. In other words, accountability must not depend on whether an official remains in office or has already left it. What must be safeguarded are legal certainty, equality before the law, and consistency in the application of legal rules.
Another issue requiring serious attention is the alleged illegal wiretapping of President Prabowo and several other individuals. This case has implications that extend far beyond the competition for influence among particular political groups. If interception was conducted without a legal basis, if surveillance systems were used outside lawful procedures, and if electronic data were deliberately deleted, the matter concerns the abuse of authority, violations of privacy, the integrity of law enforcement institutions, and the security of state institutions. Police testimony before parliament indicated that the alleged surveillance targets were not limited to the president, but also included state officials, legislators, political figures, activists, and other individuals. Investigators have also stated that they have obtained testimony from a number of witnesses, although the motives behind the operation and the identities of those suspected of ordering it still require further evidentiary examination.
The investigation should therefore focus on fundamental legal and institutional questions. Who issued the orders? Under what legal authority was the interception conducted? Were the required investigative applications and procedural authorisations obtained? Who had access to the interception system? Was the surveillance data used for particular purposes, and who was responsible for its alleged deletion? These questions are far more relevant than simply categorising the parties involved as supporters or political opponents of the president. If the interception was conducted illegally, the violation remains a serious matter regardless of whether the victims were the president, ordinary citizens, activists, journalists, or other public officials.
At the same time, caution is necessary when using terms such as treason, betrayal, or an attempt to overthrow the government. Allegations of illegal wiretapping do not automatically establish the existence of a plan to seize political power. To reach a conclusion involving treason or an attempt to overthrow the government, investigators must establish the relevant elements of the criminal offence, including the acts committed, the objectives pursued, the involvement of the parties, and the relationships among the alleged perpetrators, as prescribed by law. The designation of suspects, witness examinations, or preliminary statements by law enforcement officials cannot yet be treated as proof that the entire criminal case has been established. The presumption of innocence must remain a fundamental principle, not only to protect those under investigation but also to preserve the credibility of the law enforcement process.
Furthermore, if the alleged wiretapping involved police officials or individuals who previously occupied strategic positions, the investigation should not stop at those who technically carried out the operation. Accountability must extend to the chain of command, sources of funding, the basis on which orders were issued, oversight mechanisms, and the possible involvement of other parties. Conversely, an official’s personal or political proximity to either a former president or the incumbent president cannot substitute for evidence of involvement. Political relationships may form part of the context examined by investigators, but they must not serve as the sole basis for determining an individual’s motives or culpability.
From an institutional perspective, this case underscores the importance of law enforcement independence from political interests. The police, prosecutors, courts, and oversight institutions must exercise their authority in accordance with the law, rather than according to the interests of particular political power groups. If an investigation produces accountability only at the operational level, while those who issued the orders or benefited from the operation are never examined, the underlying institutional problem remains unresolved. Conversely, if legal proceedings are used to eliminate political opponents without adequate evidence, law enforcement loses its legitimacy and becomes an instrument of political power.
In this context, President Prabowo’s legitimacy should be assessed within a separate analytical framework. A president’s mandate derives from constitutional processes and elections, while the quality of his administration should be evaluated through its performance, compliance with the law, policy effectiveness, and institutional accountability. Legal issues involving state officials or allegations of abuse of authority within the government do not automatically invalidate the president’s mandate. However, an electoral mandate cannot be used as a justification for ignoring legal problems that arise during his administration. Criticism of the government remains necessary, but it should address actions, policies, and institutional responsibilities that can be objectively examined, rather than being constructed around assumptions about personal rivalries within the political elite.
This distinction is essential to ensure that political criticism retains an accurate and relevant focus. The Prabowo administration should be critically assessed on its ability to ensure that state institutions operate professionally, transparently, and in accordance with the law. If officials abuse their authority, the government must ensure that investigations proceed independently and are not constrained by considerations of political loyalty. If a court has established defects in an administrative decision, the relevant officials are obligated to implement the ruling. If illegal wiretapping is suspected, the state must establish who ordered it, who carried it out, who benefited from it, and how oversight mechanisms failed to prevent it. The measure of governmental success does not lie in a president’s ability to overcome the influence of his predecessor, but in his ability to ensure that state power is exercised within the boundaries of the law.
Ultimately, the central issue in Indonesian politics is not who currently holds the dominant position among political elites, but whether state institutions can preserve their integrity when political interests come into conflict with the principles of law. The dynamics of political power may attract public attention, but they should not displace more substantive concerns: officials’ compliance with court decisions, transparency in law enforcement, the protection of citizens’ rights, and accountability for the abuse of authority. Without these safeguards, political debate will remain preoccupied with assumptions about personal motives and strategies, while the underlying institutional problems remain unresolved.
Indonesia does not need political explanations that force every event into a single grand scenario. What it needs is an analytical approach capable of distinguishing facts from interpretations, political interests from legal responsibilities, and electoral legitimacy from governmental accountability. Mature criticism does not require defending the president, but neither does it require constructing conclusions based on speculation about who controls whom. In a state governed by the rule of law, the fundamental standard remains unchanged: everyone, including those at the highest levels of political power, must be subject to the law; and every allegation, including those directed at senior state officials, must be established through due legal process.
